ALUMNI

Like Wine in the River, Like Citizens of the World

Harvard Law School 2007 Student Commencement Address

Oscar Franklin Barcelona Tan (Philippines)

Posted Friday, 04-May-2007 2:07 PM

Oscar Franklin Tan is from Xavier School Class of 1997. He used to be the Editor-in-Chief of the Stallion and the CAT Corps Supplies Officer (S-4) of his batch. Kampai!

     Dean Kagan, Vice-Dean Alford, professors, classmates, families, and

friends. Let me first thank our tireless graduate program staff. They

were the first friendly faces who greeted me, told me which functions

offered free food, and what to do if you faint during your final

exams. Assistant Dean Jeanne Tai, Nancy Pinn, Heather Wallick, Curtis

Morrow, Jane Bestor, Chris Nepple, April Stockfleet: This year would

not have been possible without you.

     But this goes to everyone: Thank you all for truly making us feel part

of this community. We LLMs became your fellow students after your

Salsa Party, Chinese and Korean New Year, African Night, and our

International Party. To honor you, we took Europe by storm, winning in

the inaurgural Negotiation Challenge, in the European Law Moot Court,

and in the Willem Vis International Commercial Arbitration Moot Court.

Of course, you truly become part of Harvard Law School when you're

featured in the Parody.

     Not so long ago, Cambridge seemed a strange, unfriendly place ­

especially when I first saw Gropius. I went to John Harvard's with the

British, who began chittering in an alien language. I later discovered

it was actually English ­ the real English. I complained I was not

used to cold, but a Saudi Arabian reminded me that you can fry eggs on

a sidewalk in Riyadh. An Italian gave me tips on women because Italian

men are the world's greatest lovers, with the disclaimer that their

style does not work on American women. A Malaysian was asked to

explain the religious significance of the color of her hijab, or

headscarf. She would answer: It had to match her blouse.

     Soon, we found that great substance that keeps any law school

together: alcohol. On New Year's Eve, a Belarusian handed me a glass

of vodka, but scolded me when I began to sip it. Sipping, he

emphasized, was not the Slavic way. I shared a Frenchman's champagne,

a Peruvian's pisco sour, a Costa Rican's pina colada, a Brazilian's

caipirinha, a Mexican's tequila, and a Japanese's sake. And apologies

to the Germans, but I learned how even weak American beer enlivens an

evening when you drink it with the Irish.

     We found greater common ground: The Swiss complained about American chocolate, the New Zealanders complained about American cheese, the Sri Lankans complained about American tea, the Indians complained about the lack of vegetarian food, and everyone complained that American food makes you fat. An Austrian made homemade apfelstrudel. A Nigerian made homemade fried plantains. The Pakistanis made a non-spicy version of keema, and I only needed eight glasses of water during the meal. All the Americans had was Three Aces pizza.

     As for me, I come from the Philippines, a former American colony best

known for Imelda Marcos's shoe collection. I remember being a six-year

old watching my parents walk out of our house to join the crowds

gathering to depose the dictator Ferdinand Marcos and form human walls

against tanks. I remember being a twenty-year old in a different crowd

deposing a different but equally corrupt president.

     It was liberating to hear how a Chilean danced with crowds in the

streets when Pinochet was arrested. How the Chinese come to grips with

Tiananmen Square, while convinced that one cannot transplant

American-style government wholesale to Beijing. How life changed in

the former Soviet Union; how it was like growing up in a fledgling

Eastern European country. How a Pakistani discussed Musharraf's

assault on judicial independence with a South African worried about

Mugabe's own acts in Zimbabwe.

     It was even more liberating to hear from a Korean prosecutor how his

country sent two former presidents to jail. How the Swiss have

preserved their tradition of independence and referendum. How Ghana

threw off its colonial fetters and inspired a conscious African

solidarity. How a Bhutanese wants to help shape her constitution after

her king voluntarily gave up absolute power.

     I cannot deny that our generation's issues will be complex, but I can

guarantee that they will never be abstract, not after having a

classmate who was an Israeli army drill sergeant, not after having a

Chinese classmate with a Taiwanese girlfriend, nor after having a

classmate chased by gunmen out of Afghanistan. In fact, when George W.

Bush's speechwriter visited, my Iranian classmate introduced himself,

"Hi, I'm from an Axis of Evil country."

     Friends, my most uplifting thought this year has been that the more we

learn about each other, the more we realize that we are all alike, and

the more we inspire each other to realize our most heartfelt

yearnings. My single most memorable moment here came when I met South African Justice Albie Sachs, left with only one arm after an

assassination attempt during apartheid. My classmate stood up and

said: "South Africa is the world's second most unequal country. I come

from Brazil, the world's most unequal country, and I admire how the

South African Constitutional Court has inspired the progress of human

rights throughout the world."

     And this is how Harvard has changed us. We recall struggling with

English to keep pace with the world's most brilliant professors,

especially with Elizabeth Warren's Socratic blitzkriegs, and we thank

Harvard for raising our thinking to a higher, broader level. But even

the most powerful ideas demand passion to set them aflame. The passion

we ignite today is fueled by a collage of vignettes that will remind us in this crucible of life that our peers in faraway lands face the same frustrations, the same nation building ordeals, the same sorrows, and ultimately, the same shared joys and triumphs.

     How do a mere 700 change the world, even with overpriced Harvard

diplomas? Before a great battle in China's Spring and Autumn Period,

the legendary King Gou Jian of Yue was presented with fine wine. He

ordered his troops to stand beside a river, and poured the wine into

it. He ordered them to drink from the river and share his gift. A

bottle of wine cannot flavor a river, but the gesture so emboldened

his army that they won a great victory. We of the Class of 2007 shall

flavor this earth, whether we be vodka, wine, champagne, pisco sour,

pina colada, caipirinha, tequila, sake, jagermeister, raki, Irish

stout, Ugandan Warabi, or Philippine lambanog.

     Thus, my friends ­ and this includes our American classmates who will

soon lead the world's lone superpower ­ let us transcend our individual nationalities and affirm that we are citizens of the world. Maraming salamat po, at mabuhay kayong lahat.* Thank you and long live you all.

Go back to the top ^